As the poster you are talking about, I have seen a LOT of misinformation on these boards already about taxes, not the least of which is the notion that having an EIN can cause something bad to happen. So I try to be helpful, and instead of being glad there is actually a tax expert here offering information, I get accused of being a fly-by night tax preparer whose only education was through the H&R course -- which I did have to take to get certified to do taxes in California, and I should have been teaching the class because the instructor was clueless and gave out misinformation at least three times that I noticed.
I noticed it because I happen to have a degree in Accounting, a full four-year Bachelor's degree, Magna Cum Laude, with an emphasis in taxation which means I took additional classes in taxation that about 2/3 of my fellow class members did NOT take, and many of them became CPA's which I CHOSE not to do (I had an offer from Price-Waterhouse) because my intention was to go to law school, not to be a CPA.
I am registered with the IRS and have passed the test that over 300,000 people who have prepared taxes in this country this year have NOT yet passed, and I've been doing taxes for over 15 years for individuals (including myself), corporations, partnerships, estates, and non-profits.
How many tax returns a year do YOU prepare? I do about 140. About half of those are business returns of one sort or another. I have written a series of articles on tax preparation and small business record-keeping that ran in the local paper here.
You want to trot out your credentials before you go telling everyone here I don't know what I'm talking about?
And being an enrolled agent doesn't mean omniscience. I have had to amend tax returns done by EA's and CPA's because THEY didn't understand certain areas of the tax code, or took an easier way out instead of doing it the right way, or made errors in math. One CPA's return I amended had overcharged the client over $20,000 in tax (that I recovered) due to double counting of income and carelessness in recording the sale of one of the client's businesses.
I do not make things up. If you think I gave misinformation in my post, tell me what it was. If I'm wrong, I will correct myself. The tax code can be very nebulous at times, and some things can be interpreted in different ways. But don't malign someone you don't even know without giving them a chance to defend themselves.
I came here to the bottom of this thread to impart the knowledge that having an EIN just gives you an alternative number to give to people instead of your SSN, which can be used to commit identity theft. An EIN cannot be abused in this manner. An EIN is free to get from irs.gov and takes just a few minutes. It is also one of the things, AS I SAID IN THE MUCH-MALIGNED OTHER POST I MADE ON THE SUBJECT, that helps demonstrate to the IRS that your shopping business IS a business and NOT a hobby.
If you are NOT a business, but ARE a hobby, then don't get an EIN. It won't do a thing for you except protect you from identity theft. If you ARE a business, you still don't HAVE to have one. But it can be useful if you are audited on whether you are a business or a hobby.
The point is, if it looks like a duck and walks like a duck and quacks like a duck it is more likely to be a duck than to be a sparrow pretending to be a duck.
If you're really a business -- look and act like one. If you're not going to do what it takes to establish the seriousness of your enterprise, then don't expect to be treated like a business if you get audited.
There's a very small chance of any one of you being audited unless you are writing off large losses against other income from your shopping "business." But believe me, if you get audited, you will wish you had your ducks in a row all along because not looking like a duck may come back to bite you.
And thank you, walesmaven, for being so cordial and welcoming to a new member who tried to be helpful. I'll try to do something nice for you too someday.
Time to build a bigger bridge.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/16/2012 06:03AM by dspeakes.